In 1989, the Blues played their home games on the high school baseball field while work was being done converting the defunct softball field at the Plum City Legion Park into a facility suitable to host amateur baseball. Volunteers from the community, and members of the Blues team, helped remove fencing, backstops and bleachers to create a fabulous small town baseball field. The friendly confines of the Plum City Legion Park were complete and proudly displayed local businesses advertised on the outfield fence in the spring of 1990.

Plum City Legion Park has since hosted two WBA State Semi-finals and has been boasted as one of the finest facilities in the local area to play on. To the fans, it is far and away the best place in Western Wisconsin to watch the great game of baseball.